My precocious five-year old daughter has it all figured out: the Easter Bunny is a lie.
This year, I thought I had done an admirable job of surreptitiously masquerading as the Giant Pagan Lagomorph. Due to inclement weather, the EB (with input from his lovely pregnant bride) decided that the eggs should be delivered indoors. So while the kids were distracted upstairs, I furtively ensconced the eggs in the basement. Then I loudly informed the kids that I needed to take the trash out, but once out back, I stole around to the front and doorbell ditched the baskets. I then nonchalantly strolled in through the back door as the kids were discovering the front porch surprise, congratulating myself on a job well done. Even the CIA couldn't top that.
But a little while later during breakfast, I saw my clever daughter eyeing me skeptically. She whispered to her Grandpa Mick, "I know my Dad hid the eggs." To his credit, Gramps played along with the ruse. "How could he do it? He was taking out the trash." But she could not be dissuaded. "He hid the eggs while we were upstairs, and then he rang the doorbell when he said he was going to take out the trash."
Bingo. She had me pinned to the wall, my legs squirming like a skewered insect. "But Joy," I stammered, "how could I be the Easter Bunny? You saw me right here the whole time! Don't you believe in the Easter Bunny?"
Meanwhile, Grant mumbled, his chin dripping with jellybean juice.
So there I was, caught in the act of blatantly lying to my otherwise trusting daughter, defending an outlandishly preposterous lie. Really, what self-respecting five-year old could believe in a giant rabbit who travels the whole earth, sneaking imperceptibly into people's basements or backyards, and delivering bad candy and hardboiled eggs? This is supposed to remind her of Jesus?
In spite of my protestations and my genuine sense of loss for her already vanishing childhood innocence (I think I believed in the Easter Bunny until I was, like, twelve), another part of me swelled with pride at her intellect and her adamance. Here she was with her parents and grandparents--the most trustworthy adults in her life through whom her entire worldview was filtered--all insisting on the truthfulness of an obvious lie. Yet she stalwartly maintained her position, having the inner confidence to trust her own eyes, ears, and intuition more than this gaggle of charlatans.
With Elizabeth's help, we negotiated our way out of the situation with purposeful uncertainty: we admire you, Joy, for believing what you believe, but it's also okay for five-year olds to believe in the Easter Bunny, Santa Claus, and the Tooth Fairy
But our reassurances were beside the point. Our deception had been exposed.
Soon, we were headed to church to worship a God and His Son whose existence can be felt but never seen, never proven. I glanced in the rearview mirror at the serene smile of my angelic little girl, who seemed suddenly wise yet still blithely unaware of the morning's metaphysical significance. I reached for my wife's hand, hoping--praying--that through the years our daughter's faith in an invisible Jesus could withstand the onslaught of her mental inquisition . . . and the memory of her parents' deceit.